VS

Renault R5 vs smart #1 – Hvilken bil er det beste valget?

Begge modellene har sine styrker – men hvilken passer best for deg?
Sammenlign ytelse, forbruk, pris og plass direkte: Renault R5 eller smart #1?

Electric Vision Redefined: Renault R5 vs. smart #1

The landscape of electric vehicles has been evolving rapidly, embraced by automakers and consumers alike for their eco-friendly nature and innovative tech. In this clash of the electric titans, we delve into what the Renault R5 and smart #1 have to offer, highlighting their respective technical prowess, unique features, and what makes each of these vehicles a standout choice in the electric car market.

Design and Dimensions

The Renault R5 brings back a touch of nostalgia with its hatchback silhouette, closely echoing its iconic predecessor while being fully modernized with electric architecture. At 3,922mm in length, 1,744mm in width, and 1,498mm in height, the R5 is compact, making it ideal for urban environments.

On the other hand, the smart #1 leaps forward as an SUV, marking a departure from smart's traditionally more petite designs. Measuring in with length options between 4,270mm and 4,300mm, and a width of 1,822mm, this model embraces a more robust and spacious look, providing greater road presence.

Performance and Power

The Renault R5 is powered by a trio of electric motors that deliver up to 150 HP, synchronized with front-wheel drive and a sophisticated reduction gearbox. This setup enables the R5 to accelerate from 0-100 km/h in a respectable 8 to 9 seconds. The maximum speed is capped at 150 km/h, perfectly fitting urban and suburban driving conditions.

smart #1, sporting a rear and all-wheel drive configuration, takes performance to a whole new level with power outputs ranging from 272 HP to an impressive 428 HP. This translates to a scintillating acceleration capability, potentially rocketing from 0-100 km/h in as little as 3.9 seconds with its top-tier model. Its maximum speed reaches 180 km/h, making it a formidable contender on open roads.

Battery and Range

The Renault R5's electric heart is a 40 kWh battery with a competitive consumption rate of 14.8 kWh/100 km, offering a practical electric range from 300 km up to 405 km, depending on driving conditions and model variations. This allows the R5 to confidently handle daily commutes and occasional longer journeys.

In contrast, smart #1 offers more diverse battery configurations, with capacities ranging from 47 kWh to 62 kWh. Coupled with consumption figures between 16.8 and 18.2 kWh/100 km, it achieves a remarkable range from 310 km up to a possible 440 km. This makes it an intriguing option for those who seek extensive driving without frequent recharges.

Interior and Practicality

Inside, both vehicles provide seating for five, ensuring comfort and space for occupants. The trunk capacity of the Renault R5 stands at 326 liters, slightly edging out the smart #1’s maximum of 323 liters, although the SUV form factor of the smart #1 might offer more versatile cargo solutions with its flexible interior space.

Conclusion

Choosing between the Renault R5 and smart #1 largely boils down to mission priorities. The R5 resonates with those seeking a heritage-inspired, compact vehicle that excels in efficiency and style. Conversely, smart #1 appeals to tech-savvy drivers who desire high-performance electric mobility, with a penchant for spaciousness and swift, powerful drives.

Both models reflect cutting-edge innovation in the evolving electric landscape, marking a promising step forward in green automotive technology, showcasing how electrification can cater to diverse tastes and requirements.

Her blir det konkret: De tekniske forskjellene i detalj

Kostnader og forbruk: Når det gjelder økonomi i bruk, ser vi interessante forskjeller mellom de to modellene.

Renault R5 har et tydelig prisfortrinn – den starter på 27900 €, mens smart #1 koster 37000 €. Forskjellen er omtrent 9090 €.

I strømforbruk har Renault R5 fordelen: med 14.80 kWh per 100 km er den en smule mer effektiv enn smart #1, som bruker 16.80 kWh. Forskjellen er omtrent 2 kWh.

Når det gjelder rekkevidde, presterer smart #1 lett bedre: den klarer opptil 440 km, omtrent 35 km mer enn Renault R5.

Motor og ytelse: Effekt, dreiemoment og akselerasjon er klassiske mål for bilentusiaster – og her kommer forskjellene tydelig fram.

Når det gjelder motoreffekt, har Renault R5 et påfallende overtak – 540 hk mot 428 hk. Det tilsvarer en forskjell på omtrent 112 hk hk.

I akselerasjon fra 0 til 100 km/t er Renault R5 en smule raskere – 3.50 s mot 3.90 s. Forskjellen er omtrent 0.40 s sekunder.

Når det gjelder toppfart, ligger Renault R5 tydelig foran – den når 270 km/h, mens smart #1 stopper på 180 km/h. Forskjellen er omtrent 90 km/h.

Også når det gjelder dreiemoment, er det forskjeller: Renault R5 drar tydelig kraftigere med 4800 Nm mot 584 Nm. Forskjellen er omtrent 4216 Nm.

Plass og praktiske egenskaper: Familiebil eller hverdagskamerat – hvem tilbyr mest plass, fleksibilitet og komfort?

Begge bilene har plass til 5 personer.

Når det gjelder egenvekt, er Renault R5 tydelig lettere – 1447 kg mot 1780 kg. Forskjellen er omtrent 333 kg.

Når det gjelder bagasjeromsplass, tilbyr Renault R5 lett mer plass – 326 L mot 323 L. Forskjellen er omtrent 3 L.

Ved maksimal lastekapasitet scorer Renault R5 noe bedre – opptil 1106 L, omtrent 120 L mer enn smart #1.

I nyttelast vinner smart #1 en smule – 470 kg mot 418 kg. Forskjellen er omtrent 52 kg.

Hvem stikker av med seieren?

Alt i alt viser Renault R5 seg å være gir konkurrenten liten sjanse og sikrer seg dermed tittelen som DriveDuel Champion.
Den utmerker seg med en bedre totalpakke og er den mest allsidige bilen i hverdagen.

fra ca. € 27 900
D9BB3E56-4B0D-4E48-A734-11A1714B92A5

Renault R5

  • Motortype : Elektrisk
  • Girkasse : Automat
  • Drivtype : Forhjulsdrift, Bakhjulsdrift
  • Effekt hk : 122 - 540 hk
  • Forbruk kWh/100km : 14.8 - 15.2 kWh
  • Elektrisk rekkevidde : 307 - 405 km
detaljer

Renault R5

5 (1)
vurder

R5 er en imponerende bil som kombinerer klassisk design med moderne teknologi. Med sitt sporty utseende og agile kjøreegenskaper, appellerer den til både entusiaster og dagligdagse sjåfører. Enten du kjører på landeveien eller i byen, leverer R5 en spennende og komfortabel opplevelse.

detaljer
D9BB3E56-4B0D-4E48-A734-11A1714B92A5 @ media.renault.at
79A3C149-BC71-4BE3-A149-986DD84D251C @ media.renault.at
DDEACB99-545B-4C72-B12C-AB35E7B77365 @ media.renault.at

smart #1

Den nye Volkswagen ID.4 setter standarden for elektriske SUV-er med sitt stilige design og imponerende rekkevidde. Innvendig tilbyr den god plass og moderne teknologi som gjør kjøreopplevelsen både komfortabel og intuitiv. Med fokus på bærekraft og ytelse, er ID.4 et spennende valg for de som ønsker en miljøvennlig, men samtidig kraftfull bil.

detaljer
P018_DSCF1498_EU @ Smart Deutschland
Limbo_Edition1_EXT_25_White_Gold_front @ Smart Deutschland
Limbo_Edition1_EXT_09_White_Gold_Powered_Tailgate @ Smart Deutschland
Limbo_Edition1_EXT_07_White_Gold_Powered_Top @ Smart Deutschland
Limbo_Edition1_EXT_05_White_Gold_side @ Smart Deutschland
P009_DSCF2991_EU @ Smart Deutschland
P012_DSC_1017_EU_New @ Smart Deutschland

Lignende bilsammenligninger

Suzuki S-Cross
Suzuki Vitara
VS
The Suzuki S‑Cross and Vitara live in the same family but play different roles: the S‑Cross is the sensible, spacious commuter while the Vitara is the cheeky all‑rounder with a touch more character. The S‑Cross wins on practicality — bigger boot, roomier rear seats and a cushier ride for long miles — while the Vitara dishes out sharper steering, bolder styling and peppier engine options for those who want a bit of fun. Choose the S‑Cross for economy and family duties; take the Vitara if you prefer personality and a small SUV that’s more adventurous than anonymous.
Skoda Enyaq
Skoda Elroq
VS
In the ever-evolving landscape of electric SUVs, the Skoda Enyaq and Skoda Elroq stand out as formidable contenders. The Enyaq impresses with its spacious interior and advanced tech features, while the Elroq offers a sportier design and a more dynamic driving experience. As both models leverage Skoda's commitment to sustainability and innovation, potential buyers will have to consider their priorities when choosing between these two striking electric vehicles.
Renault R5
smart #1
R5
#1

Kostnader og forbruk
Pris
27900 - 160000 €
Pris
37000 - 52500 €
Forbruk L/100km
-
Forbruk L/100km
-
Forbruk kWh/100km
14.8 - 15.2 kWh
Forbruk kWh/100km
16.8 - 18.2 kWh
Elektrisk rekkevidde
307 - 405 km
Elektrisk rekkevidde
310 - 440 km
Batterikapasitet
40 - 52 kWh
Batterikapasitet
47 - 62 kWh
co2
0 g/km
co2
0 g/km
Tankkapasitet
-
Tankkapasitet
-

Mål og karosseri
Karosseri
Hatchback
Karosseri
SUV
Seter
2 - 5
Seter
5
Dører
3 - 5
Dører
5
Egenvekt
1447 - 1524 kg
Egenvekt
1780 - 1900 kg
Bagasjerom
326 L
Bagasjerom
313 - 323 L
Lengde
3922 - 4080 mm
Lengde
4270 - 4300 mm
Bredde
1744 - 2030 mm
Bredde
1822 mm
Høyde
1380 - 1498 mm
Høyde
1636 mm
Maks bagasjerom
1106 L
Maks bagasjerom
976 - 986 L
Nyttelast
396 - 418 kg
Nyttelast
425 - 470 kg

Motor og ytelse
Motortype
Elektrisk
Motortype
Elektrisk
Girkasse
Automat
Girkasse
Automat
Gir detalj
Reduksjonsgir
Gir detalj
Reduksjonsgir
Drivtype
Forhjulsdrift, Bakhjulsdrift
Drivtype
Bakhjulsdrift, Firehjulsdrift
Effekt hk
122 - 540 hk
Effekt hk
272 - 428 hk
Akselerasjon 0-100km/t
3.5 - 9 s
Akselerasjon 0-100km/t
3.9 - 6.7 s
Maks hastighet
150 - 270 km/h
Maks hastighet
180 km/h
Dreiemoment
225 - 4800 Nm
Dreiemoment
343 - 584 Nm
Antall sylindre
-
Antall sylindre
-
Effekt kW
90 - 397 kW
Effekt kW
200 - 315 kW
Slagvolum
-
Slagvolum
-

Generelt
Modellår
2025 - 2027
Modellår
2023 - 2024
CO2-effektivitetsklasse
A
CO2-effektivitetsklasse
A
Merke
Renault
Merke
smart

Lignende bilsammenligninger

VW ID.4
Skoda Elroq
VS
In the battle of electric SUVs, the VW ID.4 and Skoda Enyaq offer distinctive features that cater to different preferences. The ID.4 boasts a more refined interior and advanced tech options, while the Enyaq shines with its spaciousness and practicality. Ultimately, the choice between these two electrifying rivals comes down to personal priorities, whether it's premium driving experience or superior cargo capacity.
Skoda Kamiq
VW T-Roc
VS
In the battle of compact SUVs, the Skoda Kamiq holds its ground against the VW T-Roc by offering excellent value for money without sacrificing essential features. While the T-Roc boasts a more premium interior and sportier styling, the Kamiq impresses with its practicality and spacious cabin, making it a favorite among families. Ultimately, choosing between these two contenders will hinge on whether drivers prioritize style or functionality in their everyday rides.
Toyota C-HR
Toyota Yaris Cross
VS
In a head-to-head comparison of the Toyota C-HR and the Toyota Yaris Cross, both compact SUVs showcase innovative design and versatility, appealing to urban drivers. While the C-HR brings a more striking aesthetic and a sporty driving experience, the Yaris Cross offers greater practicality with its spacious interior and advanced hybrid options. Ultimately, the choice will depend on whether you prioritize style or functionality in your daily commute.
Lexus LBX
Toyota Yaris Cross
VS
Think of the Lexus LBX and Toyota Yaris Cross as sibling rivals: they share the same hybrid bones, but the LBX wraps them in sharper styling, quieter materials and a premium badge that commands a higher price for finesse. If you crave Lexus polish and cabin calm, go LBX; if you want smart practicality, better value and fewer awkward conversations about leather upkeep, the Yaris Cross is the savvier buy.
CUPRA Formentor
CUPRA Terramar
VS
In the dynamic showdown between the CUPRA Formentor and the CUPRA Terramar, enthusiasts are treated to a blend of style and performance that defines the brand. The Formentor, with its striking design and agile handling, appeals to those seeking a sportier SUV experience, while the Terramar offers a more robust package with advanced technology and spaciousness for families on the go. Ultimately, both models showcase CUPRA's commitment to delivering exhilarating drives, making the choice a thrilling dilemma for buyers.
Toyota Yaris Cross
Toyota Yaris
VS
In the battle of compact versatility, the Toyota Yaris Cross takes the lead with its SUV-inspired design and elevated stance, catering to drivers who prioritize a raised driving position and additional space. Meanwhile, the traditional Toyota Yaris remains a favorite for urban dwellers, excelling in fuel efficiency and maneuverability in tight city streets. With advancements in technology and safety features across both models, prospective buyers are presented with compelling options that suit a variety of lifestyles.
Dacia Jogger
Dacia Bigster
VS
The Dacia Jogger is the no-nonsense family hero — seven seats, huge practicality and wallet-friendly running costs that make it perfect for school runs and flat-packed furniture missions. The Dacia Bigster ups the ante with SUV styling, more interior space and a tougher road presence, trading a bit of the Jogger’s economy for extra comfort and on-the-road confidence. Pick the Jogger if you want maximum value and seating, choose the Bigster if you crave more space, style and a bolder look for a few extra quid.
Renault Austral
Renault Rafale
VS
In this exciting comparison, the Renault Austral takes on the Renault Rafale, two standout models in Renault's latest lineup. The Austral impresses with its agile handling and spacious interior, making it a strong contender for urban drivers. Meanwhile, the Rafale showcases a bold design and advanced technology, appealing to those seeking a more dynamic driving experience.
Hvilke drivlinjer finnes for Renault R5?

Renault R5 er tilgjengelig med Forhjulsdrift eller Bakhjulsdrift.

De viste prisene og dataene er estimater basert på tyske listepriser og kan variere avhengig av land. Denne informasjonen er ikke juridisk bindende.